I know I’m not Italian but I also know this is not Italian. It’s the bottom shelf of the Kroger freezer section, I understand covid hurt but, if you can’t do a pescatore then just please don’t. For crab they used imitation crab stix, the scallops seemed to be quartered and not even sautéed maybe just boiled, the shrimp was so tiny and genuinely questionable. If I get sick I just would not be surprised, I’ll be surprised if I’m fine. There is a pool of olive oil, genuinely you could have saved at least 3/4ths of this. The wine was great (it was in a bottle) and the service was amazing. I’m sorry I wouldn’t serve this to anyone much less for almost $20. I’ve been cat-fished, this place has all the makings for an amazing family style Italian restaurant from the man who greeted us to the white table clothes and well dressed service. I’m stunned.

The atmosphere was incredibly authentic and what we first noticed when walking in the door. We were seated comfortably on the waiting couch for a table to become available and the staff was quite friendly. The food was wonderful. Although the dining area is quite intimate and multiple conversations are going on at once making it hard to hear, overall it was a very pleasant first time experience and we would come back again.

The food was real and authentic. It was real authentic! We went to celebrate our 3rd wedding anniversary. We had the Roman Bread with no olives (the gorgonzola was stronnnggg and so was the peppercorn), my hubby had the escargot (he loved it) I had the Tonys Own Fettuccine and it was 🤌🏾🤌🏾🤌🏾chefs kiss! with the wedding soup which was absolutely divine. My husband had the Fettuccine Pescatore and it was delicious 😋. Everything was very tasty, I would love to go back again! The limoncello and apple martini were both very nice as well! And the cannoli for dessert was a wonderful ending.

Go eat at Z Cucina do Spirito.The inside scope!Here is a little bit of background on myself. I have been in the culinary field for 28 years. I have been classically trained at Johnson & Wales university and certified through American culinary Federation.The maître d’ is the owner Tony & the bartender’s name is Chuck. What you read about these two individuals and their bad attitudes are 100% correct! The vast majority of their reviews above three stars are from their family, friends and their regulars. The people cooking in the back of the house are not trained in the culinary field. Tony only hires cheap inexperienced labor. There is no “executive chef“!The cleanliness in the kitchen is mine blowing. If you ever have the urge to eat there and the back door is open take a quick look and you will see exactly what I’m talking about when it comes to cleanliness.Now let’s talk about the food. All the desserts are frozen, nothing is made in house. 95% of the menu was created back in the 1980s and never has been updated. The white sauce/Alfredo sauce are one in the same but on the menu it gives you the impression that they are two different sauces which they are not. The white sauce is made with very low quality products. The crab that is on the menu is imitation crab let me repeat myself it is imitation low quality crab! The lasagna is not made daily!The only positive part of this establishment is the dining area. It has that old German Village feel. If memory serves me right the restaurant used to be an old horse stable. Very beautiful dinning area.In summary, don’t waste your time because all you’ll get is bad attitudes from the owner and bar tender to go along with the low quality food that is thrown together by untrained cooking staff.It’s about time that Tony and Chuck retire and pass along this beautiful restaurant to someone that will take great pride in providing wonderful customer service and serves high quality food.

Great food and atmosphere. Everything we tried was delicious, including the calamari puttsnedca, caprese, eggplant parmesan, tiramisu and cannoli.

Obviously you dont feel its important to post your menu on your website. Well. I think it is. So I moved on. Get out of the 80s and update your website. People actually use it to choose a restaurant. It may improve your traffic. Bye bye.

The food was amazing!Our server, Jeff was so good. Great, friendly service. The Calamari, Fettuccine and Linguine with meatballs!

Upscale dinning in a beautiful setting. The service was impeccable. I really appreciate the varied menu options. It was time and money well spent.

This was the most terrible Italian restaurant that I have ever been to. There were many things on the menu that sounded good however everything that we got was bad. Including the service which was the most terrible of all. We never got our drinks filled, our table was never pre-bussed, the server helped other servers close down their section instead of bringing us parmesan cheese, another fork, napkins, and some things that we needed to eat our meal. In addition to that the server was very flighty and kept mentioning off subject creepy things. It was just a really weird experience. The only thing I did like was the cream sauce that came on the The spinach and cheese catalonies; however, it tasted like They used frozen spinach on the inside.. The appetizer bread also tasted like it had been frozen previously. Also I think there was more seasoning around the plate and on the edges then there was on the actual food. Our salad had no flavor at all and it was just lettuce, with oil and one pasta noodle. The croutons were old crunchy bread. Id never go back.

Old favorite. Chose for my birthday! Killer limoncello cake for dessert.

This place was amazing! The wedding soup tasted just like my grandmas from Italy. Everything was delicious, we will be back and probably frequently.

I was very excited to come here today, and when my friend and I got there we received a very off putting look from who I assume was the manger or owner. We asked for a table outside and he told us to wait 10 minutes, even though there were plenty of open tables. I politely understood he request for us to wait, and after 15 minutes of us waiting and him standing around staring at us from a far I started to get agitated. Then shortly after that he decided it was time to seat us. He brought us out to the table, gave us no eye contact, tossed the menus and walked away. This led us to just getting up and leaving. I want to acknowledge that the waitress did acknowledge us as soon as we walked outside, kindly saying “I’ll be right with you guys” and “Are you guys leaving?” I appreciate her for that! We headed over to Cafe Napolitana where we had great food and much better respect and service!

Tony is usually there looking spiffy he takes a lot of pride in his restaurant. This restaurant feels like youre in Italy for dinner. Very high class and intimate setting . Exceptional service and an extensive wine list and variety of Italian cuisine.

Walked past this place and it looked nice so decided to give it a try. Definitely will be back after eating a most excellent eggplant parmesan.

Went last night for dinner. The man who seated us was indifferent towards us. The server groaned as he walked up to us to pour our waters. On that note I told my boyfriend we could either leave now or just get drinks as I didn’t want to be such a burden on the people who we would have been tipping that night. Server seemed doubly annoyed that at that point we were only getting drinks. The bartender was great and ended up being the one taking care of us as the server obviously had better things to be doing other than his immediate job. Very interesting that other reviews also note the rude and unwelcoming service. Went down the street to local cantina instead and they were awesome, they had never even heard of Tony’s when I told them of our terrible night there lol. I definitely don’t care enough to go back to try the food, which other reviews describe as only a little better than the bad service.

A wonderful restaurant! This was my second time and everything is delicious and the service is wonderful! Kyle was out server and hes great! I recommend the Roman bread for an appetizer especially if you like blue cheese. TheVeal Saltimbocca is mouth watering good. Tonys Own fettuccine put me outside my comfort zone. Its a seafood pasta with a cream sauce. That to was very good and I would have both again. My friends all had different items. They all taste good. I posted a picture of my first cosmopolitan. Go to Tonys and enjoy some real Italian food!

We was so disappointed after reading the reviews. We had the meatballs and spaghetti and meatloaf. The meatballs and meatloaf taste the same very mushy and had absolutely no flavor. The marinara sauce on the meatballs did not have the nice tomato flavor that you would expect from a true Italian restaurant. The spaghetti sauce was just as Bland.

Ordered carry out, food was delicious but it would have been nice if utensils and napkins would have been included as I was staying in a hotel. My fault for not checking but just thought they would have included it.

Beautiful restaurant, great food and amazing staff. My husband and I was out for a night on the town, we stopped in at 9 only a few people were in the restaurant, out waiter was kind and attentive. He brought everything out in a timely manner, very friendly. I ordered the marsala (amazing) my husband had the Carbonara. Overall great experience, I will be coming back for more.

I went with 2 of my friends and we absolutely loved dining here! The restaurant was beautiful and plenty of parking. I felt very covid safe. We really enjoyed our food! My 2 friends raved about the fish & chips! I loved my salad with chicken! The homemade dressing was very fresh & healthy. We had the best mozzarella sticks ever! We would all go back again! The waitress, Julie was very friendly & attentive! Thanks!

Fantastic classic Italian cuisine with several well thought out seafood dishes. Salmon (ask for it medium but well seared if you are like me) with spinach, mushrooms and cannellini beans is one of the best dishes I have ever eaten. Some of the other dishes with shrimp, scallops and crab over linguini or salad are always cooked perfectly. Great service to boot. You will not be disappointed.

Food and service were good. Expensive.

The food is outstanding, the wait staff wonderful, and the restaurant is beautiful. Everything is simply terrific. We definitely will be back.

In joy every minute there, the food was the best Italian restaurant that I have been to!!! They made it a very special day for me. Our waiter was right on point!!! Great food and Great service... Damn good drink!!! What more can you ask for... Be more than happy to go back there...

This little place had great ambiance and the server was knowledgeable about the menu, but for the price, the food was just okay. My stepdaughter described it best; its a one note dish.

Subpar food at unreasonable prices. Garlic bread was good

Tony was great, he had the outside closed but he opened it up for us and we loved the food!

Very very good! Everyone was great! The place is beautiful and the food is amazing!

Food was good, the spinach was a little salty...

Very cozy place. Traditional Italian. Delicious food, wonderful time.

Authentic atmosphere, delicious food, great service. Would definitely recommend and plan to return!

Amazing Fettuccini!! We love coming here, the staff is so friendly.

I ordered delivery from Tonys. They did not include the garlic bread that I ordered. The spinach and ricotta cannelloni was barely edible -- parts of the pasta were burnt, and the filling tasted old and extremely salty. Clearly did not use fresh ingredients.

Great atmosphere and nice selection of items on the menu; Tonight I had Ciopino, all our dishes were delicious and the service was great. The owner Tony, takes great pride in his restaurant & greeted us when we arrived.

Nice atmosphere and good food.

It was just O K...1st time there and was expecting more

Excellent food. Service was top notch. Will make sure to visit again.

Excellent high end Italian restaurant! Top notch service and cuisine. Great place for a date night.

Great Italian food.... loved the bread and herb butter!!! Best service ever!

Good but not best food

Chicken rotini is a 10/10!! The pesto sauce on it is amazing!!!!

Love Tonys food, especially the lasagna!

The service was amazing but the food was a joke. $20 for pasta that did not fill me up and had no flavor.

The food, atmosphere, and service were wonderful! I will have to come back again.

First visit to Tonys. It has the vibe of a really nice Italian restaurant, but the pricing is very affordable. Feels like a classic space in german village. Great service. The food was good but not mind blowing. Ill definitely be coming back to try some different options. I chose eggplant parm for this first visit.

Ill start with this - Tonys is a beautiful restaurant with classic décor and ambiance, fitting your perfect local Italian restaurant vibe. We walked in feeling great, grabbed a drink at the bar, but that was the best part of my experience.To start, we ordered the Sausage & Peppers app; the sausage came out almost completely raw. When we told who I assume to be Tony, it felt like pulling teeth for him to remedy the situation.Next, we ordered our entrees - Veal Piccata & I ordered a Tonys Own Fettucini but subbed in Tortellini, which may have been a mistake. Anywho - salads came out and they must have grabbed a handful out of the Kroger Spring Mix bag and tossed a little olive oil on it- not what I expected from a high-end Italian Restaurant. My meal lacked flavor, depth, seasoning; I felt like it was no better than frozen Tortellini mixed with jarred alfredo. My ladys dish was heavily over salted and almost too much for her to eat.After the meal, Tony came up and asked if he could buy us a dessert for the appetizer blunder, which we thought was quite kind. We got the Tiramisu. Well, the Tiramisu came out FROZEN. That about put a bow on our experience.Maybe was just an off night for them, but from the food to the service, we left quite disappointed. Hard to think about returning at this point.

Placed a carryout order and the host was very rude. Tall with purple shirt tried to treat me as I was infected. Tried to tell me where to sit as I waited, so I waited in my car. Brought my order out and set it on the sidewalk instead of bringing it to my vehicle. Not very diverse atmosphere treated me as I didnt belong. Whether they tend to my kind or not, I will never go back. Food was of poor quality not authentic. I wouldnt waste my time there, but you can see if they serve Your Kind??!!

Love this place!! If you are looking for authentic Italian food, I highly recommend this restaurant!!

First and last time at Tonys. From the awkward acknowledgement(cant call it a greeting...we felt like we were interrupting Tonys day), to the 3 half dollar size pieces that comprised my $20 Veal Marsala, this was a waste of time and money. Note to the chef: Marsala dishes should have at least one mushroom! So laughable that I sent this pic to a friend who said it looked like his cat vomited on the plate. Do not recommend!

Food,service,staff and atmosphere was awesome

Excellent food and service!! Love the ambiance

Man this would be ideal for like a wedding party its such a nice environment and has a romantic touch to it. Very professional staff!

Great food and atmosphere is cozy. Skilled wait staff.

Fast, friendly service and delicious food.

Great food and friendly staff.

Used to love Tonys but hadnt been in probably 15 years. Went on Saturday for a special dinner with my Mom and sister and remembered why I loved it! What a warm and cozy atmosphere! Service and food were great too! It was clear right off the bat that there are a lot of regulars... I see why!!!

Great food, service sAnd drinks

Excellent place for dinner! Service was great and the food was fantastic. Price was very reasonable for the quality. Great atmosphere if you are looking for a relaxing dinner. Highly recommended!

Amazing food

Food was tasty. The mushroom appetizer was tantalizing. Eggplant parmesan was tender, light, and flavorful. Meatballs were incredible. The pastas we had were wonderful. Atmosphere was nice. Wait staff was excellent.

Met Tony tonight. Super nice. I had a great time. The food and atmosphere was awesome. Great to patronize a locally owned establishment like Tonys.

5 stars for the food and decor, however 1 star for the service my family and I received. Server literally approached the table and said sternly, What do you want? Throughout the course of the meal, we received refills on our drinks one time, which we had to ask for. Food was fantastic though!

The service was mediocre. Food was OK - more rich and filling than focused on flavor. Id say if you just wanted to fill up on cheese and pasta for a medium to high price this place is fine, but if you are looking for fresh delicious Italian food go elsewhere.

Excellent food great service!

Tony and his staff are as good as it gets! Enjoy or of Tony’s specialties (or anything really it’s all delicious!) in a cozy setting, or grab a seat at the bar. Best Italian for miles.

Went here for the first time with co-workers and it was great. Very relaxing place. Everyone was very friendly. I had a seafood pasta and it was delicious. I would recommend this place if your in the mood for Italian food.

Iceberg lettuce hidden under 3 leaves of spinach with house Italian that is just vinegar. Dry tasteless chicken on the fettuccine Madonna in puddle of oil. Tonys fettuccine had overcooked shrimp and mystery chopped up seafood. Would NOT recommend wasting your money there.

The food tasted odd, the owner was quite rude to my wife when we came in. Nice atmosphere but the staff seemed to be a bit on edge. The evening would have been a one star with the exception of our waitress Dorinda who was pleasant, attentive, and professional.

The food is authentically Italian and is excellent. The atmosphere feels somewhat upscale, but you still feel a warm welcoming, like youre part of the family. The prices are very modest. The restaurant was fully seated, but Tony helped us get a table as quickly as possible, combining two tables for our group of 6 to be seated within a half hour on a busy Friday night.. Great service. A+

Love Tony’s ! Never had a bad meal there. The chicken liver appetizer is the best ever! Highly recommend it!

Food, service & atmosphere were fab. Will visit again. First time. Got blackened salmon.

Everything I have ordered here has been fresh and delicious. The wine is good, and priced reasonably. Gregory’s service is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. We will be back!

We had great dinner at Tonys! We had not been there in quite a while and we all said we need to come more often. The food and service was outstanding!

Good food and service

Yummy food and good service.

Nice place great foodNice place great food

The food is not what it used to be there some ministries soup tasted like salt brine. The Tonys PastaFettuccine seafood dish Sauce was thick, and I could still taste the flour.

I worked here recently for one week. The owner is a NIGHTMARE. Incredibly misogynistic and odd. The most depressing place I have ever worked. And NONE of their pasta is homemade, all of their desserts are frozen. Menu says the opposite. Food was okay. I will never support this business again.

Excellent pasta. You can tell everything was freshly prepared. The limoncello cake was also very good. Server was top notch too. Only complaint was that we were seated next to the exterior brick wall and it was very chilly.

The service was great food was about average for the meal I got, prices seemed fair. The inside of the restaurant was very nice, good environment will definitely be coming back for another meal sometime soon.

Very delicious.

Great place for dinner, excellent food and service. Reasonable prices, white tablecloths, parking behind restaurant and across alley in evenings. Great for date night or dinner with family and friends. Enjoy

The veal is cooked in a natural garlic sweetness with top quality olive oil, and if possible I would marry it and be happy for the rest of my days.

Always good service and food. More a 4.5 than a 4. Had lamb chops and eggplant parmesan and both were great. Always greeted at the door and welcomed in.

In the middle of “chaos” I can always retreat to Tony’s where I will find the comfort of Italian food. From the fettuccine, lasagne to the Spumoni.... I can always count on Tony’s for a fine dining experience in a totally relaxed atmosphere. Side bars - outdoor patio, private dining rooms (seating up to eighty), parking...and something we rarely see in today’s corporate food chain world... the namesake! Got to love Tony!

Great food and great service.. My husband and I have been going there for years on our Anniversary. And in between. They made our night very special. I recommend Tonys Own seafood fettuccine dish that is amazing!

Awesome food, friendly fast service great dinning experience. You have got to try Tonys Own Fettuccine. Absolutely amazing.

So in love with this place. Every time I visit Columbus I come here for dinner. Wedding soup is fantastic. Some might think its a bit salty, but I like it that way. Bits of egg and chicken. Really good. Do yourself a favor and get the Roman Bread. To die for. The Tiramisu is some of the best Ive ever had.

Delicious food. Old school Italian for sure. You can expect to see appetizers and menu items that only an old school Italian chef could create. If you have never experienced such savory simple delicacies, then this is a “must”for you. The service all around was warm, attentive and inviting. A very friendly environment along with a Full service bar. The wine list is outstanding to pair your meal with. Highly recommended.

Our waiter had an attitude for no apparent reason. He never gave his name. The manager seated us while he grabbed a few menus from a disorganized stack up front.No welcome: no enjoy your dinner. I asked the waiter about a couple of the entrees: he shrugged and said not much difference.His apathy was explained when i got my food. Over cooked pasta, mediocre sauce, &bland fish. We all agreed that we wouldnt come back.

My wife took her team out tonight for their Christmas party. The main course was cold. Not lukewarm....cold. All three dishes...the chicken, the pasta and the pasta vegetables. We were told they would take them back and re-warm them. Re warm????? Seriously? $500 for dinner and you offer to re-warm? Maybe....re-make?Does your food come from GFS and you re-warm it and serve it as yours?Really a bad experience tonight. Embarrassed for my wife. She tried to give her team a nice dinner. You guys fell on your face tonight.

Nice birthday dinner or my daughter and family. Service snd food very good

Nice banquet facility. Not very warm or cozy for day to day meals. Service was good. Meal -- veal marsala -- was well prepared. Portions are large. Most entrees come with choice of a cup of soup or a salad, plus a side of pasta.

Not a great experience. We ordered carry out, and the food was weak (and that is being kind). First they got our order wrong and we had to go back in. The food itself was very low quality (ingredients) for the price and the salad looked like it had been in the container for days. Pasta was no better. Such a shame because we live very close. Will not be back.

Love this place! Best authentic Italian food Ive had in Columbus! They also have a recently renovated room (with a full bar) you can rent for private parties upstairs.

The food was outstanding. The four people in my party all enjoyed their meals. Great service too!

Great ambience, lackluster food. Upon walking in, I was impressed by the cozy decor of the main dining room. Service was pleasant, but the food was utterly flavorless apart from the wedding soup. I got the signature linguine dish and was terribly disappointed. The alfredo-like sauce was congealed into a gel and no amount of salt and pepper could save the dish. My partners Italian sausage and pasta dish was nearly as bad; the only things of flavor were the few pieces of sausage. Sorry to say I wont be going back.

First time out of town customer. Easy online ordering process and order/delivery tracking was great. Delivery driver greeted me smiling and thanked me for ordering.Pizza was prepared to my request, hot and the cookie.... YUMWould reorder on my next trip.

Average italian food at best. Decent service. Would not recommend. They would not honor our groupon.

Nice little Italian eatery. Its a bit upscale, so Id recommend attire to match. Decent Italian food (some might say great, but Im the Olive Garden type) and great service. It looked like there might be private rooms available. Theres a bar too.